Should You Buy an Analog or Digital Scanner?

11.8K

So you’ve got a little bit of money set aside and you really want to focus in on your post-disaster comms. You don’t feel like you need another transceiver at the moment, but there is one piece of equipment that’s missing from your ham shack: a scanner.

The problem though is this: you know that there are two types of scanners out there – analog and digital – and you can’t decide which one you should get. What do you do? Should you buy an analog or digital scanner?

Why Buy an Analog or Digital Scanner in the First Place?

To start with, if you’ve ever used a transceiver such as a Baofeng UV-5R, you know that the scanning speed is abysmally slow. Time can very easily be life, particularly within a disaster setting – and this isn’t a luxury that can be afford to be wasted.

Consider if you know there’s a call for help somewhere out there on the 2m band after a disaster. Your elderly dad lives all the way on the other side of town and you’d purchased a ham radio for him as part of a disaster kit. Should all go to crap, at least dad would be able to get in contact with you.

But you forgot to establish a comms window. You never set up a designated set of frequencies to talk on, nor did you set up a designated time to talk. You’ve a pretty good idea that your dad is on the radio trying to reach you (let’s say there’s been a foreign troop invasion and you live in Alaska), you just don’t know which frequency.

You can try to scan all of the 2m band with your little Baofeng radio, but by the time you reach 146.500, your dad may very well have finished his broadcast for help.

This is where a scanner comes in to play. They’re very, very fast. If you’ve already programmed in a set of frequencies into your memory, they’re lightning fast as well. This speed with scanning through a part of the radio spectrum can have a number of uses, aside from the one listed above.

What if a Hurricane Katrina type event takes place, you’re trapped in your attic due to rising flood waters, and are searching for where the radio traffic is? A scanner can help you find it quickly.

What if you’re monitoring your local police frequencies to keep a close eye on the nearby “burn the city” riot? A scanner can help you to ensure you don’t miss anything important.

What if you’re trying to find actionable intel about a roving band of looters post-SHTF which is known to use radios for group comms? A scanner will help you to better determine which frequencies the looters are operating off of.

In short, a scanner is a fantastic piece of gear which can both provide you with a lot of information in a hurry and make your job of finding that information much easier.

The Advantages of an Analog Scanner

There is one predominant advantage to an analog scanner and that is the price. For all of $100, one can purchase a scanner which will allow them to start listening to a lot of traffic that’s taking place over the radio spectrum.

Think about this: how many people do you know that are involved with ham radio? If you’re well inserted into the prepper scene, probably more than the average joe, but still, the numbers are slim, right? While ham numbers have most certainly skyrocketed the past two years, we’re still a very small minority within the US.

That being the case, think about a post-collapse situation. World War 3, Civil War 2.0, or some other violence has taken place. Perhaps you have the motorcycle gangs of Joe Nobody’s series. Maybe it’s groups of organized looters roving about as in Rawle’s Patriots.

Whatever you have, do you think that those people are likely to be communicating with digital radios or with analog? Before you answer that question, consider which you are more likely to see in a Walmart, Bass Pro Shops, or Gander Mountain: analog FRS/GMRS walkie-talkies or digital ham radios? Without a doubt, what you’ll see are FRS/GMRS walkie-talkies. So that being the case, what do you think those gangs and looters are likely to use?

The answer? Analog.

And for $100, you can get in the game of listening.

The Disadvantages of an Analog Scanner

While the price of analog scanners is very cost-friendly, there’s a reason for that: analog technology has been around forever. And as time goes on, technology is improved and/or replaced. The same has happened within the field of radio. Digital modes were created, and they gradually spread throughout the radio world. The problem with using an analog scanner is that these digital modes can be pervasive, particularly within the world of the uniform.

If you’re mainly wanting to listen in on police frequencies or unencrypted military talk (yes, it does exist), you’ll be wasting your money on an analog scanner. The reason for this is that both of these groupings of people have almost fully made the transition to digital mode radio.

Sure, it depends on where you live, but for the most part, this is the direction that police departments are headed. A county which doesn’t use digital mode radios for their police is often considered as backwards or behind-the-times within the police community.

You can check if your specific locale uses digital or analog for their police department by looking at RadioReference.com. If you don’t, and you buy an analog scanner, you’re not going to be able to listen in on any of the talk you were hoping to pick up at all. Analog cannot pickup digital mode.

The Advantages of a Digital Scanner

I would argue that the chief advantage of a digital scanner is that you get more bang for your buck. With digital scanners I can listen to both digital and analog signals.

Police frequencies? Check.
Seasoned hams? Check.
EMS teams? Check.

It’s all there. A digital scanner allows you to hear it all.

If you’re looking for a one-and-done purchase, you want to listen to as much of the radio spectrum as possible, and you’ve truly got an interest int listening to anything attached to the government’s payroll, then you’re going to want to invest in a digital scanner right off the bat.

The Disadvantages of a Digital Scanner

There is one disadvantage, I think, to digital scanners.

It’s the price. These things are expensive. Unless you have $400 to drop, you’re not even going to be able to start to get in the game with digital scanners. While I do think that there are good preps to save for, and that this is a superior piece of equipment to analog, I do have a few drawbacks to this price.

For starters, it’s the preps you have which come in handy in a disaster, not the prep still on the store shelves. If The Event kicks off and you have $300 in your hand but no scanner, well, you don’t have a scanner. Definitely prep according to your means as well. $400 is simply too cost prohibitive for a lot of people.

What are Some Good Analog Scanners?

Uniden is perhaps the largest player in the world of scanners, so you’ll see their name pop up frequently in any discussion of such. Here are a few good analog scanners to consider:

Uniden Bearcat BC125AT

A small, handheld unit, this is a good model to consider if you’re looking for something to strap onto your kit as you head out into the woods. As of this writing, it only costs $115, and you get a pretty standard selection of features for your money.

Close call is present, you can store 500 channels organized in 10 different memory banks (very convenient. This allows you to separate your police frequencies, FRS frequencies, EMS frequencies, etc.), and runs off of two AA batteries.

Uniden Bearcat SR30C

For only $100, you can add the SR30C to your ham arsenal. This is a bare bones unit, though, so be aware. You’ll get close call and 500 memory channels, but that’s about it. That’s not to say this is useless, it just doesn’t have as many of the bells and whistles as a lot of the other scanners out there.

Whistler WS1010

This Whistler WS1010 runs for $80. That’s as cheap as it gets when you’re looking for a scanner. It’s been around forever though, and it has a pretty solid following. If you’re looking for something simple to use, with basic functions, and that will get you listening to analog signals, check this one out.

There are some reports of antenna problems with the rubber duck, but that’s fairly common with all rubber duck antennas. If you can find/build a different antenna, you’ll get better reception strength.

What are Some Good Digital Scanners?

Looking to drop a bit of cash on something which will let you pick up virtually the full gamut of what you’d be able to pick up? Then check out some of the below…

Uniden HomePatrol-2

A friend of mine runs a Uniden HomePatrol-2 just about every day and absolutely loves it. You can pick up just about any digital mode transmission out there (P25, Motorola, EDACS, LTR) with this, but it is going to set you back $460.00. The attribute my friend really enjoys about this scanner is the fact that he never has to program anything.

All you have to do is punch in your zip code and the scanner will automatically set itself up to monitor the frequencies/repeaters in your area.

If you’re averse to computers or not tech-savvy, this might be something to consider.

Uniden BCD436HP HomePatrol

Someday, I’m going to find the $500 to shell out for this. It’s a pretty sweet unit. The Uniden BCD436HP is a handheld unit, and much easier to use in the field than the Uniden HomePatrol 2. (I actually wouldn’t recommend the HomePatrol 2 for a BOB. I don’t like that large of a screen with me in the woods. Too much potential for getting broken!)

If you shell out for a BCD436HP, you end up with Close Call tech, GPS ability, the ability to scan 85 channels per second (in the stored channels), the ability to automatically find the frequencies which correspond to your zip code, and more. Seriously, this is an awesome unit.

Whistler WS1040

This is actually a fairly popular unit with a lot of guys out there. At $250, it’s not going to break the bank either. I’ve personally never owned a Whistler, but they’re a respected brand, and you get a lot of cool features with the WS1040.

You can store up to 1800 frequencies, it picks up P25 Phase 1 & 2, DMR, and more. It runs off of two AA batteries (ubiquitous), and is worth checking out if you’re not a fan of Uniden.

Uniden SDS100

Got cash? Then you may want to check out the SDS100. This bad boy is right around $700. You get a lot for that money though. You can pick up virtually anything (provided it’s not encrypted), it’s rated as IPX4 and JIS4 (meaning it’s tough), and runs off of the HomePatrol database of US frequencies.

Personally, if given the choice, I would still rather run the BCD436HP (I know more about it, know more guys that run it, can actually dream about being able to afford it, etc.), but if money’s no option, then you may want to consider this the Uniden SDS100 as well.

Searching for Some Final Thoughts

Haha, see what I did there? Searching. Whoo. *wipes tear*

Should you add an analog or digital scanner to your disaster comms toolkit? I think so. Absolutely. Even if you only have the money to drop on an analog scanner, there is still a bounty of information you’ll be able to glean in a disaster situation when everybody and there brother starts hopping onto the radio spectrum. They provide a lot of benefit for a very little investment.

And for a bit more of an investment you can pick up something which will give you information overload. Either way, I think it’s a win.

So, check out some of the above designs. Consider adding one of these analog or digital scanners to your BOB, your ham shack, and your faraday cages. After The Event takes place, you’ll be glad you did.

---